Wellington + 64 4 496 9990
Lower Hutt + 64 4 569 4873
Masterton + 64 6 370 6480

Articles and News

Email me when new posts are made to this blog
Is rugby going soft? - The new high tackle laws explained

By Richard Gordon

Is rugby going soft? - The new high tackle laws explained

Richard Gordon works in the Sports Law team at Gibson Sheat. He is a current first-class national referee, Wellington’s number one club referee, and the resident in-house rugby laws expert. He has spent the last two years refereeing the Mitre 10 Heartland Championship throughout the provinces, from Westport to Ruatoria.

January 1 2017 saw World Rugby introduce new tackle laws – cracking down on contact with the head. This has been seen as a response to several high-profile concussions during Test Matches (think Sam Cane v Robbie Henshaw in the second Ireland Test in 2016), and is part of a general bid by World Rugby to make the sport safer.

Whilst we haven’t really seen these laws implemented in the Southern Hemisphere yet, the reaction in the Northern Hemisphere has been mixed at best, and hugely controversial. Many pundits, ex-players, and members of the public have been vociferously complaining along the lines of “rugby has gone soft”, “rugby is turning into football”, and “the game is being ruined”. These critics point to an increase in yellow and red cards dished out for high tackles, some of which could be considered very harsh.

But let’s pause for a second. What has actually changed?

The law hasn’t changed – the definition of a high tackle today is the same as it was three years ago.

Only the sanctions being imposed have changed. There are two buzzwords you’re going to hear lots when a referee is dealing with a high tackle:

  1. Reckless. A player is deemed to have made reckless contact during a tackle or attempted tackle or during other phases of the game if in making contact, the player knew or should have known that there was a risk of making contact with the head of an opponent, but did so anyway.

    - Minimum Sanction – Yellow Card
    - Maximum Sanction – Red Card 
     
  2. Accidental.  When making contact with another player during a tackle or attempted tackle or during other phases of the game, if a player makes accidental contact with an opponent's head, either directly or where the contact starts below the line of the shoulders, the player may still be sanctioned. This includes situations where the ball-carrier slips into the tackle.

    - Minimum Sanction – Penalty

Some of this may come across as harsh – “isn’t there a risk of making contact with the head in any tackle?”, “how can it be a penalty if the ball-carrier slips?” – but as Ireland prop Tadgh Furlong has said:

“When it comes to protecting the head and neck of players, everyone is rightly very cautious now. Rugby is a physical sport and there will always be a level of injury risk associated with it but the sport is doing as much as it can to make it as safe as possible.”

World Rugby is not changing the law. World Rugby is simply making it clear and obvious that culpability for these types of tackle rests on the head (ahem) of the tackler.

Like any rule change or interpretation change, it will take a ‘settling-in period’ for both referees and players alike. Expectations and opinions take time to readjust. Yes we are going to see more cards given for high-tackles. Yes, you will not agree with all of them.

However it is important to note that like any rugby law, the referee on the field is the one that interprets the law to the fact situation in front of him/her. In order to keep the complaints from the general rugby public to a minimum, referees are going to have to show common sense. The referees who understand what players are trying to achieve are going to be the ones making decisions that make sense. 

It will certainly be interesting to see what happens in Super Rugby.

 

1 Comments

Your comments
ninjadeden says ...
ya apakah kami memiliki kelompok yang lebih muda danling 6
agen astm a283 c
agen pipa boiler
agen plat abrex 400
agen plat asme516 grade70
agen plat astm a285 c
agen plat astm516 70
agen plat boiler
agen plat hardox
agen plat hb 400
agen plat high strenght
agen plat high tensile sm490 yb
agen plat high tensile sm490ya
agen plat kapal
agen plat stainless ss304
agen plat stainless ss310
agen plat stainless ss316
agen plat sumihard
agen round bar besi aisi 440s45c
agen round bar scm440
agen steel rail
agen steel sheet pile
distributor astm a283 c
distributor pipa boiler
distributor plat abrex 400
distributor plat asme516 grade70
distributor plat astm a285 c
distributor plat astm516 70
distributor plat boiler
distributor plat hb 400
distributor plat high strenght
distributor plat high tensile sm490 yb
distributor plat high tensile sm490ya
distributor plat kapal
distributor plat stainless ss304
distributor plat stainless ss310
distributor plat stainless ss316
distributor plat sumihard
distributor round bar besi aisi 440s45c
distributor round bar scm440
distributor steel rail
distributor steel sheet pile
jual astm a283 c
jual baja h beam
jual pipa boiler
jual plat abrex 400
jual plat asme516 grade70
jual plat astm a285 c
jual plat astm516 70
jual plat boiler
jual plat hardox
jual plat hb 400
jual plat high strenght
jual plat high tensile sm490 yb
jual plat high tensile sm490ya
jual plat kapal
jual plat stainless ss304
jual plat stainless ss310
jual plat stainless ss316
jual plat sumihard
jual round bar besi aisi 440s45c
jual round bar scm440
jual steel rail
jual steel sheet pile
pabrik astm a283 c
pabrik pipa boiler
pabrik plat abrex 400
pabrik plat asme516 grade70
pabrik plat astm516 70
pabrik plat boiler
pabrik plat hb 400
pabrik plat high tensile sm490 yb
pabrik plat high tensile sm490ya
pabrik plat kapal
pabrik plat stainless ss304
pabrik plat stainless ss310
pabrik round bar besi aisi 440s45c
pabrik round bar scm440
pabrik steel rail
pabrik steel sheet pile
pusat astm a283 c
pusat pipa boiler
pusat plat abrex 400
pusat plat asme516 grade70
pusat plat astm a285 c
pusat plat astm516 70
pusat plat boiler
pusat plat hardox
pusat plat hb 400
pusat plat high strenght
pusat plat high tensile sm490 yb
pusat plat high tensile sm490ya
pusat plat kapal
pusat plat stainless ss304
pusat plat stainless ss310
pusat plat stainless ss316
pusat plat sumihard
pusat round bar besi aisi 440s45c
pusat round bar scm440
pusat steel rail
pusat steel sheet pile
stockis plat hardox
stockist plat astm a285 c
stockist plat high strenght
stockist plat stainless ss316
stockist plat sumihard
supplier plat hardox
plat stainless ss201
plat sphc po
plat putih spcc sd
plat hitam ss400
plat hitam sphc
plat corten
plat astm a36
plat alumunium
plat abrex 500
plat abrex 450
plain bar
pipa sch80
pipa sch40
pipa sch160
pipa sch120
pipa sch10
pipa medium galvanis
perforated plate
grating size galvanis
expanded metal
deformed bar
besi wiremesh
besi unp
besi cnp
besi baja wfbeam
baja h beam